Been reading alot of Marvel stuff lately, so I decided to get into some DC reading.
Superman Earth One... a great book that I think everybody should read, very accessible and I would gladly recommend to a non-comic reader
After Superman Earth One, it kinda got me on a Superman kick...
For Tomorrow... Great art, cool story (albeit confusing at parts) something Superman needed 6-7 years ago
Son of Superman / Bizarro World... 10 or so issues written by Geoff Johns and Richard Donner (the director of Superman 1+2) pretty cool stuff for anyone that likes the first 2 Superman movies it flows well with those movies' storylines'
All-Star Superman... Such a strange book. Most writers try to ground Superman, make him more real, or depower him... Grant Morrison instead makes him more powerful and more fantastical, which totally works in this collection of mostly one-shot stories with a subtle underlying story.
Bizarro Short Stories 1 + 2 Superman for All Seasons (by Jeff Leob and Tim Sale)
The above covers all of the Superman I have and I assume all of the Superman stories worth reading out of the 1000s that have been published.
Superman is the most iconic comic character ever with prob a lower batting average than Cable when it come to good stories about him ; )
Realizes that I now have nothing to look forward to since Battlestar finished